Page 1 of 1

Chi-square values < 1

Posted: 2018.06.15 10:16
by BC_Flügge
Hello,

I try to build ab initio models with DAMMIF/GASBOR and I am always getting Chi-squares values < 1 (usually, around 0.4 - 0.6) no matter what. In my opinion, the raw data looks really good, but I am just a SAXS beginner. I also agree with the generated models as I have a crystal structure to check. I already read that too low Chi-square values are a matter of over-fitting, but I used the data as autognom generated them without changing anything. I will enclose the raw data and images of the fitted curves. As I really want to use this data, I hope for your help. Thank you in advance.

Cheers!

Re: Chi-square values < 1

Posted: 2018.07.23 16:08
by AL
BC_Flügge wrote:
2018.06.15 10:16
I try to build ab initio models with DAMMIF/GASBOR and I am always getting Chi-squares values < 1 (usually, around 0.4 - 0.6) no matter what.
The experimental errors (3rd column in your HtrASn.dat file) are clearly overestimated - that's why the chi-squared values are too low.

Re: Chi-square values < 1

Posted: 2018.08.03 07:54
by BC_Flügge
Thank you for the reply. And what can I do to avoid overestimation?

Re: what can I do to avoid overestimation?

Posted: 2018.08.03 12:51
by AL
Redo the radial averaging. E.g. if you use pyFAI - switch "pixel splitting" to "No splitting".